San Junipero initial analysis
- Belinda Carlisle - Heaven is a place on earth - a fascinating song choice, as it establishes a narrative theme of the episode, that heaven, the afterlife could be a place on earth. Yet it is also a trashy, catchy 80s banger that has popularity and cultural significance.
- A prominent theme of this episode is nostalgia, and how nostalgia functions as the gratification of escapism. It explores hedonistic lifestyles and criticises as well as celebrates a life lived in total pleasure. It also explores the function of nostalgia, the idea of eternal youth, and how nostalgia provides comfort and rehabilitation. It also explores the negative aspects of nostalgia, and how a perfect memory may be misleading.
- A science fiction narrative that completely challenges sci-fi conventions
- The aesthetic is extremely well realised, especially the 80s aesthetic with, costume, music, hairstyles, videogames, language…
- Nostalgia is complex and it is possible to be nostalgic about something we have never experienced. Our experience and understanding of the world comes not from direct experience but through consumption of media, from representation. Stuart Hall argued that representations construct reality, and our understanding of the world comes through re-presentation
- LGBT relationships are represented as normalised and significant. While Yorkie’s sexual awakening is essential to the narrative, arguably there are other themes that are more important
- Intersectional feminism: bell hooks argues that feminism is a complex political act based on identity traits. Kelly is a complex character in terms of ethnicity and sexuality
- The afterlife and belief in a Judeo/Christian god.
- The simulation hypothesis: do we live in a virtual world? What is reality? What is love?
- The beach setting: calm, peaceful, a glorified version of reality, a representation of reality that is better than the thing which is being represented. Hyperreality!
- Nostalgia is a romanticisation of the past. The 80s are often romanticised yet were a time of inequality, racism, sexism, AIDS, terrible music and so on.
- The narrative is extremely complicated and even impenetrable. Nothing is made clear for the audience, forcing them to come to their own conclusions. However, upon rewatching, there are many proairetic codes that help the audience to fully understand the narrative. Digitally convergent streaming platforms now allow for media that necessitates being watched and rewatched.
- Lots and lots of popular licenced music reflects the time and setting, but also has other function
- The shift between decades is marked by a movie poster that is displayed outside Tuckers. This suggests that we associate time with things such as media to provide our perception of reality. Stuart Hall argued that reality is a representation, and our understanding of reality comes through representations. So we can understand history even if we were not present! \the stereotypical assumptions constructed through media feel far more real that reality…
- Nostalgia is an essential theme of the episode. As we age we become more nostalgic, and start to look back at when times were better. San Junipero is immersive nostalgia therapy, and in this context, SJ is a method of coping with the inevitability of death, while also providing a ‘real’ afterlife. The 80’s is constructed through the MES of big hair, a blue and red colour palette, 80’s hits, and distinctive 80s costumes. The 80s here are depicted as perfect, with no homophobia, sexism, racism, ugly people or hangovers. When Wes bothers Kelly she asks “do I have to red light you?”, providing another utopian solution, making SJ into a sanctuary. However, in actuality, the 80s were homophobic, sexist, and plagued by economic issues. The nostalgia that Yorkie feels for the 80s is a false one, based on hyperreal constructions of culture.
- Hyperreality - a version of reality that feels more real than the thing being represented!
- SJ can be linked to the biblical concept of heaven. Here heaven is constructed as something real and physical, yet the rules of entry are different. Perhaps the episode is criticising Christianity? It certainly presents euthanasia in a positive, gentle and liberatory way.
- Yorkie and Kelly both upload their ‘souls’ and memories to the cloud, to enable a copy of themselves to exist forever. However, this raises an existential issue that is not addressed in this episode! However, these themes are included to appeal to sci-fi fans
- However, even sci-fi hating audiences can enjoy the queer romance that is depicted in the episode. Audiences may negotiate this as purely positive. Jenkins argued that fans can engage in media products however they want, and the sapphic fan art of Kelly and yorkie demonstrates this is what many audiences desire. However, Kelly and Yorkie have a deeply toxic relationship. Yorkie encourages Kelly to kill herself, and essentially to be married to her forever. Kelly keeps ghosting Yorkie, Yorkie keeps following Kelly, and Yorkie is mentally a confused 21 year old, while Kelly is in her mid 70s…
- While the episode is science fiction it is completely unconventional. There is very little futuristic technology, no lasers, no aliens. Instead, SJ is largely a period drama, albeit with a postmodern twist, and provides audiences with something new and exciting.
- Yorkie has been in a coma since she was 21. Now in her sixties, she still behaves like a 21 year old. She gets excited about going to clubs, is reluctant to drink, and dresses in a naïve, awkward, and an agendered way. When entering the club, she nervously walks around, reinforced through a tracking shot, that constructs a binary opposition between her and the other partygoers. Yorkie is clearly the nerd archetype, and her big round glasses confirm. However, Kelly is in her mid 70s, is confident, is sexually promiscuous vs Yorkie’s sexual monogamy. There is an age gap romance that provokes the audience.
- San Junipero is a virtual world. It is a videogame. It is an MMO RPG, where many different users interact with each other and a range of NPCs. It resembles games like the Sims, where users escape into a utopian simulation. In San Junipero, the verbs are romance, drive a car, fight, build a house, hang out by the beach, and drink at a club. However this utopia is ultimately one dimensional. There is no room for growth or actually living.
The functions of genre
- It allows audiences to make decisions on their viewing choices. It allows audiences to discover media products that they already know they like, thus maximising revenue for producers
- It allows producers the opportunity to effectively target audiences
- It allows producers to understand what is the most popular genres on the market, and adjust schedules accordingly
San Junipero, genre, narrative and intertextual relay
Polysemy is predicated on intertextual relay: How can audiences use intertextual relay to further understand the narrative of San Junipero?
- The dress up scene, where Yorkie tries on a number of different outfits accompanied with period appropriate music, constructs a complex narrative for the audience, all predicated on their ability to negotiate intertextuality and to participate in intertextual relay.
- Firstly, the format of the sequence will clearly be familiar to many audiences, taking the form of a dress up montage. This narrative concept, popular in romantic comedies such as Clueless, allows the producer to communicate with the audience complex aspects about character. It is fun, light hearted yet important. In this sequence, every costume is wildly different from another, and every costume is an explicit intertextual reference to another text.
- One aspect of media language that is used to create explicit and polysemic interpretations is the use of intertextual relay in the dress-up montage. Dress up montages are a convention of the ‘chick flick’, and helps to symbolise a change that has occurred.
- The montage opens with Girlfriend in a Coma by the Smiths. The Smiths were an art rock/indie band famed for making extremely depressing music. Yorkie further references this through her big glasses, symbolic as her status as a nerd and outcast. Yet most importantly, the selection of song (which required a ridiculous amount of money to licence), functions as a proairetic code, and bluntly tells the audience that Yorkie is in a coma.
- Next, Yorkie instantly changes clothes to resemble the character Claire from the 1986 John Hughes teen movie The Breakfast Club. The lyrics, Don’t You (Forget About Me), clearly refer to Yorkie’s obsession with Kelly. Yet the intertextual construction of her outsit also has the significance of constructing Yorkie as an outcast. However, Yorkie chooses to dress as Sheedy post-transition, from awkward nerd to cool girl. This ridiculously complicated aspect of intertextual relay suggests that identity is fluid and can be changed.
- The first song, Girlfriend in a Coma by the Smiths, was the most expensive aspect of the entire episode. Clearly essential to the narrative, the title explicitly spells out to the audience that actually Yorkie is in a coma. Yet moreover, the music of The Smiths is shorthand for a kind of stereotypical misery and depression popular in 80’s music.
- However, yorkie switches the song off, desperate to change her image. We cut to Yorkie dancing to Simple Mind’s song Don’t You (forget about me), while dressed like Ally Sheedy’s character in The Breakfast club, after she has had a significant makeover. This not only reflects Yorkie’s desire to sleep with Kelly, but also her desire to reinvent herself and to attract others
- Finally, Yorkie dresses as one of the backing dancers from the video to Addicted to love by Robert Palmer. Not only does this refer to her obsession with Kelly, it also communicates a desire to become an object of fetishization. This is constructed through the MES of black tights, tight dress, blank face and an intimidating stare. By constructing herself as a fetish, Yorkie believes she will make herself more exciting and attractive, a notion that is highly relatable to many audiences.
- Finally, Yorkie dresses as a background dancer from the famous video to Addicted to Love. Dressed in a tight black dress, sheer tights, black kitten heels, scaped back hair, emotionless, rocking back and forth… Yorkie presents herself as an exciting sexual fetish, self objectifying in order to appeal to Kell. However, Yorkie rejects all of these specific intertextual narratives, choosing to ‘be herself’. However, this is completely subverted by the realisation that yorkie is really an old woman in a coma
- The sequence explains the Yorkie is trying to find herself, exploring a range of different characters and genres. This construction of herself through media is a perfect example of the postmodern condition.
Outrun (1986) and San Junipero
San Junipero and allegory
- Identity - Playing different roles, roleplay, escapism, refusing to face actual physical issues, the essential nature of escapism
- Life after death - Death is a huge taboo, and to face it is difficult. This episode deals with death and the possibility of an afterlife using the mechanisms of science fiction, in particular the digital world of San Junipero
- Hedonism - excessive lifestyles are explored in both a positive and negative well: San Junipero is both heaven and hell
- Euthanasia/suicide - promotion of suicide is illegal in the UK! However, it is justified in it’s depiction of euthanasia. However the sci-fi elements allow this sensitive topic to be dealt with
- Toxic relationships - Yorkie as a manipulator, Kelly ghosts Yorkie, different expectations… These are all things that audience members are likely to have experienced… the sci-fi elements make them more relatable, eg the setting of Tuckers as an infinite party…
- Anxieties surrounding technology - digitally convergent technology causes us anxiety not only through what it does to us but what it will do. Addition, stopping creativity, lack of employment, global insecurity
- Sex and intimacy - the use of dating apps and social media for sex and relationships is explored
- The afterlife - instead of conventional Christian ideas of heaven/hell, in SJ, consciousness can be uploaded to the cloud. Corporatisation of religion? Buying in to the afterlife…
- Heaven as a graveyard - San Junipero is referred to as a graveyard by Kelly, which implies a false paradise. SJ is extremely limited, yet to Yorkie, it s a liberatory paradise
- Social care, and what we do with the terminally ill - the sci fi conventions help to smooth out this essential topic. San Junipero is nostalgic therapy!
- Criticism against religion - Kelly’s faith is challenged, and yet she ends up in sj. May challenge religious audiences. Uploading the soul to the cloud
- Queer relationships and homophobia - Yorkie’s struggle to come out to her parents
- Euthanasia - arguments about coercion, generally represented positive
- Toxic relationships - both K+Y are manipulative, ill suited with each other, with a massive age gap
- AI, technology, phones, digital convergence - Ai has many issues. Hyperconnected, damaging to society, replacing humanity
Key scene analysis – the establishing montage - how does media language construct meaning in this sequence?
- The sequence contains a number of intertextual references that construct meaning for the audience. Firstly, Yorkie is distracted by a shop display of CRT scenes showing 80’s icon Max Headroom. Originating from a sci-fi cyberpunk show set 20 minutes into the future. Max Headroom criticises 80s television culture with a postmodern hero who lives inside a television. It demonstrates themes of identity and confusion, which reflects Yorkie’s state of mind… Furthermore an arcade machine is established through a long pan that ends abruptly on the machine Bubble Bobble, symbolically encoding that Yorkie is far more interested in videogames than dancing, and also suggesting that yorkie belongs to the nerd archetype. Furthermore, the title Bubble Bobble helps to proairetically suggest that Yorkie’s existence is simply to be trapped in a bubble
- The costumes are period appropriate for the 1980s, and construct a clear sense of setting and belonging. However, on closer inspection we realise that everyone is wearing similar clothing, with about six outfits repeated to infinity. Kelly remarks that “everyone tries to look like what they think they should look like… probably took it from a movie”. This indicates that the geriatric users of SJ have constructed their identity through genre conventions rather than lived experience. It constructs a hyperreal simulation that is better than any reality.
- The colour palette is bright, inviting and yet completely artificial. In particular, the colours blue and pink saturate everything. This colour selection is highly polysemic, and can connote a gender binary, yet also symbolises the 1980s, a stereotypical and hyperreal construction.
- Throughout the deep focus tracking shot that follows Y through the club, she is rendered through a long shot. This cinematographic choice clearly encodes that Yorkie is isolated, alone even, a clear binary opposition that will engage any audience who has felt like a social outsider. We are further positioned with Y through the use of a connotative O/S shot, positioning the target audience in an intimate mode of address. We are forced through media language to sympathise/empaphise with her, a common narrative trick.
- Yorkie walks in a guarded, rigid way. Her head moves with her body, and is hunched over, suggesting that she is out of place and feels she doesn’t belong. This is a diametric opposition to Kelly who is larger than life, confident, strutting, and wearing enormous shoulder pads. This opposition explicitly tells the audience that these opposites should not meet, yet also ties in to a narrative cliché, that opposites attract.
- Sound also constructs complex meanings When Yorkie enters the club, the pleonastic diegetic upbeat 80s music situates the audience in a compelling 80s setting. However, as Yorkie progresses, the sound mix magically dips, and allows for an intimate, natural conversation that would be impossible in a real club. It is a perfect hyperreal simulation, a version of a club that could not exist. Additionally, Tucker has no obvious use of drugs, no bouncers, no creeps, no ugly people and no drunk people.
- The selection of costumes is highly evocative, and perfectly captures the zeitgeist of the 1980s. The MES of the patterns, colours, polka dots, oversized glasses and oversized hair all capture a stereotypical perspective of an era that the target audience will have no experience of. It constructs a hyperreal simulacrum of not only the 1980s, but also clubs, being young, and culture. The MES of the partygoers constructs all as young, hegemonically attractive, clean and sober. Rather than a realistic representation of hedonism, it presents a hyperreal representation that is familiar to anyone who has witnessed a club scene in a film or TV show. Everything is a representation, and Tuckers is essentially a false reality.
- The tracking shot that follows Yorkie through the club firstly tracks her in an O?S shot, but then Yorkie quickly becomes lost in the crowd as it transforms into a long, panning establishing long shot. This has the effect of establishing Yorkie as an anomaly, as different from the crowd, as other to everybody else. This constructs her as the typical nerd/weird girl archetype that will be familiar to audiences through intertextual relay and their knowledge of films like The Breakfast Club (TBC). This culminates in Yorkie choosing to paly the arcade game Bubble Bubble, further confirming our suspicions. A male nerd archetype appears, yet surprisingly, Yorkie ignores him, challenging our expectations. This not only forms a proairetic code, suggesting Yorkie is queer, it also constructs a reality where identity is extremely complex. Yorkie is a nerd, yet does not identify as one.
- The setting of the street outside tuckers is constructed through elaborate MES, period details, and represents a ‘normal’ night out in the 1980s. The third shot of the episode pans down from an enormous poster of The Lost Boys. An overheard diegetic radio broadcast plays Belinda Carlisle, and an advert on a TV, playing the sci fi show Max Headroom, a chaotic cyberpunk show about media saturation. This helps us to understand the pessimistic outlook of Sj, but it also confirms something more important. By basing our understanding of the 80s on media products, instead of a historically accurate setting, we are instead left with hyperreality.
- The lighting is bright, dynamic, stereotypically 80s, and a binary opposition to the quietness of the night. Pink and blue are most often depicted, which clearly functions as a symbolic code. Firstly it functions as a binary opposition to the dull, boring nature of Yorkie’s costume. It resembles the aesthetic of modern videogames, 80s throwback films like Bladerunner 2049 and Drive, and stereotypical gender binaries. This last point is contradicted by the complex queer relationship constructed by Kelly and Yorkie.
- The choice of song represents Yorkie’s feelings
- CUs of Yorkie’s face position audience with her
- Camera cutting from the long take of the club to establish the arcade suggests this is all a videogame
- Kelly introduced through her loud shouting that attracts Yorkie
- Contrast between people dancing and lonely yorkie
Bricolage - The combination of different media forms, styles and elements to construct something new and distinct
The final sequence as a site of affect; how can Barthes' concept of the punctum help us to understand intense emotional responses?
- A trashy pop song recontextualised…
- The reference to a nostalgic videogame…
- The use of montage, cross-cutting between a fatal dose of poison and a car winding down a round…
- The blinking, endless lights of a soulless server farm…
- Spinning…


.jpg)
.jpg)

